The Monsters of the Midway meet Philadelphia’s fearless underdog champions.
Affiliate Disclaimer
This blog may contain affiliate links or banner advertisements. If you click on one of these links or advertisements and make a purchase, The Shopping Plaza may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. These commissions help support our work and allow us to continue creating free sports content, rankings, tournament features, and Legacy Showdown matchups like Gametime Gauntlet. We only recommend products, services, or merchandise that we believe may be of interest to our readers. Thank you for supporting The Shopping Plaza and Gametime Gauntlet.
The Matchup
The NFL Region opens with a true David-versus-Goliath matchup. The #1 seed 1985 Chicago Bears enter Gametime Gauntlet as one of professional football’s most intimidating historical heavyweights. Chicago finished 15-1, unleashed the legendary 46 Defense, and turned the postseason into a demonstration of defensive power. The Bears combined Hall of Fame talent, personality, swagger, and overwhelming results into a season that still appears near the top of greatest-team debates.
The #16 seed 2017 Philadelphia Eagles arrive with a completely different kind of championship story. Philadelphia built an elite team, lost starting quarterback Carson Wentz late in the season, and then watched backup Nick Foles guide the club through a postseason run that ended with the franchise’s first Super Bowl championship. Rather than collapsing after losing an MVP-caliber quarterback, the Eagles adapted, trusted their depth, and ultimately defeated the New England Patriots in one of the most memorable Super Bowls ever played.
Gametime Gauntlet does not ask which team would literally win under one era’s rules. Each champion is judged relative to its own time across ten consistent categories. Philadelphia brings resilience, depth, and a fearless postseason story. Chicago brings historic dominance, defensive greatness, and an enduring claim as one of the best teams ever assembled.
- Dominance Over Competition
Chicago’s 15-1 regular-season record immediately establishes the scale of its dominance. The Bears did not merely win frequently; their defense created an atmosphere in which opponents often appeared to be playing uphill from the opening possession. Chicago could control field position, force mistakes, pressure quarterbacks, and allow its offense to operate without needing to chase games. The postseason made the argument even stronger, as the Bears overwhelmed their NFC opponents before finishing the championship run with a decisive Super Bowl victory. Philadelphia’s 2017 team was excellent and earned the NFC’s top seed, but its season became defined more by resilience after adversity than by the same level of week-to-week intimidation. The Eagles deserve credit for surviving the loss of Carson Wentz and continuing to win, yet Chicago’s full-season command is simply on another tier. Dominance Over Competition goes to the 1985 Bears.
Winner: 1985 Chicago Bears
- Championship Achievement
Both teams won Super Bowls, and both championships occupy special places in their franchises’ histories. Philadelphia’s victory delivered the Eagles their first Super Bowl title and completed an extraordinary run with a backup quarterback. Chicago’s championship, however, served as the final confirmation of a season that had already looked historically dominant. The Bears carried enormous expectations into the playoffs and responded by becoming even more imposing when the stakes increased. Their postseason did not feel like a narrow escape from elimination; it felt like the completion of a campaign in which the league’s best team repeatedly proved its superiority. Philadelphia’s title has the stronger underdog element, but this category rewards the total championship achievement rather than drama alone. The Bears take the point.
Winner: 1985 Chicago Bears
- Strength of Competition
Philadelphia earns its first category because its championship path culminated against one of the defining dynasties in NFL history. The Eagles faced a New England Patriots team led by Tom Brady and coached by Bill Belichick, an opponent with extensive Super Bowl experience and a proven ability to punish mistakes. Philadelphia entered that game without Carson Wentz and still had to match an elite opponent possession for possession. The Eagles did not survive by hiding their backup quarterback; they trusted Nick Foles and attacked aggressively enough to win a high-scoring championship game. Chicago faced strong competition in 1985 and dominated its playoff path, but the source matchup gives Philadelphia the edge for the caliber of the final obstacle it overcame. Beating a dynasty-level champion under those circumstances gives the Eagles a powerful Strength of Competition argument. Philadelphia takes the category.
Winner: 2017 Philadelphia Eagles
- Star Power
The 1985 Bears possessed the kind of star concentration that can define an entire era of football. Walter Payton was already one of the sport’s most celebrated running backs and gave Chicago an offensive centerpiece worthy of the defense surrounding him. Mike Singletary became the commanding presence in the middle of the defense, while Richard Dent and Dan Hampton helped make the front seven terrifying to block. Beyond the biggest names, the Bears featured memorable personalities whose identities became part of the team’s mythology. Philadelphia had excellent players throughout its roster and several stars who played crucial roles in the championship, but Chicago’s collection of historically recognizable talent is deeper at the very top. The Bears combined elite individual accomplishment with a unit whose stars became symbols of defensive football itself. Star Power belongs to Chicago.
Winner: 1985 Chicago Bears
- Depth and Supporting Cast
Philadelphia deserves enormous respect in this category because its championship became a demonstration of organizational depth. Losing Carson Wentz could have ended the season, yet Nick Foles stepped into the most important position on the field and eventually delivered a championship performance. The Eagles also relied on a deep defensive front, a versatile offense, and role players capable of absorbing injuries without destroying the team’s identity. Chicago, however, had exceptional talent across the roster and could overwhelm opponents through more than one defensive star or one offensive weapon. The Bears’ depth allowed the 46 Defense to function aggressively because multiple players could pressure, cover, tackle, and create turnovers within the scheme. Philadelphia’s depth made its title possible, but Chicago’s overall talent level remains stronger under the original matchup’s judgment. The Bears take a competitive fifth category.
Winner: 1985 Chicago Bears
- Historical Impact
The 1985 Bears became more than a champion; they became a reference point for defensive football. Their 46 Defense, coordinated by Buddy Ryan, helped create an identity based on pressure, disruption, intimidation, and forcing offenses to react before plays could fully develop. The team’s personality also expanded its cultural footprint, making the Bears recognizable far beyond ordinary game results. Philadelphia’s 2017 championship transformed the emotional history of the Eagles franchise and gave the city a long-awaited Super Bowl celebration. Yet Chicago’s impact reaches into broader conversations about defensive schemes, dominant units, championship swagger, and the greatest teams in NFL history. Decades later, coaches, players, analysts, and fans still invoke the 1985 Bears when a defense begins approaching historical territory. Chicago wins Historical Impact.
Winner: 1985 Chicago Bears
- Statistical Excellence
The numbers behind Chicago’s defense support the mythology surrounding it. The Bears allowed only 198 points during the regular season while finishing 15-1, creating a statistical profile that reflected both scoring prevention and extraordinary consistency. Their defense produced sacks, turnovers, short fields, and the kind of repeated disruption that changed how opponents had to call games. The postseason only strengthened the statistical case, with Chicago recording consecutive shutouts before allowing just 10 points in the Super Bowl. Philadelphia’s 2017 team was balanced and statistically strong enough to earn the NFC’s top seed despite late adversity. But this category asks which team produced the more extraordinary measurable season relative to its era. Chicago’s defensive numbers and 15-1 record make the Bears the clear choice.
Winner: 1985 Chicago Bears
- Longevity of Greatness
This category is less about whether the exact championship roster repeated as champion and more about how long the team’s greatness remained meaningful in football history. The 2017 Eagles were part of a competitive organizational period and their championship remains one of the franchise’s defining achievements. Chicago’s 1985 team, however, has endured for more than four decades as a fixture in discussions of the greatest NFL teams ever assembled. The defense has been compared with nearly every elite unit that followed it, and the season remains a benchmark even for fans born long after 1985. That kind of historical staying power gives the Bears a form of longevity that extends beyond the lifespan of the roster itself. The source matchup treats this enduring place in greatest-team debates as the deciding advantage. Chicago takes Longevity of Greatness.
Winner: 1985 Chicago Bears
- Clutch Performance
Philadelphia’s second point comes from the way the team responded when its championship hopes appeared most vulnerable. Losing Carson Wentz late in a Super Bowl-caliber season could have shattered the Eagles’ momentum, but the roster refused to allow one injury to define the ending. Nick Foles delivered under playoff pressure, the coaching staff adapted the offense to his strengths, and the team continued winning against opponents that knew exactly where Philadelphia’s apparent weakness should have been. The Super Bowl provided the ultimate test, with the Eagles trading scores against Tom Brady and New England rather than retreating into a conservative game plan. Critical plays required confidence, execution, and a willingness to remain aggressive even when the championship hung in the balance. Chicago’s postseason was dominant, but Philadelphia’s path demanded more repeated responses to adversity. Clutch Performance goes to the 2017 Eagles.
Winner: 2017 Philadelphia Eagles
- Legacy Endurance
The 1985 Bears remain one of the rare teams whose season can be identified almost instantly by year alone. Their defense, 15-1 record, postseason dominance, personalities, and Super Bowl victory have kept the team prominent in football culture for generations. Whenever analysts rank the greatest defenses or greatest single-season teams, Chicago is almost guaranteed to enter the conversation. Philadelphia’s 2017 championship has a powerful legacy of its own, especially for Eagles fans who waited generations for the franchise’s first Super Bowl victory. The story of Nick Foles and the underdog run will continue to hold a special place in modern NFL history. But Chicago’s legacy operates on a broader league-wide level as a benchmark for all-time greatness. The Bears take the final category and complete an 8-2 victory.
Winner: 1985 Chicago Bears
Gametime Gauntlet Scorecard
- Dominance Over Competition: 1985 Chicago Bears
- Championship Achievement: 1985 Chicago Bears
- Strength of Competition: 2017 Philadelphia Eagles
- Star Power: 1985 Chicago Bears
- Depth and Supporting Cast: 1985 Chicago Bears
- Historical Impact: 1985 Chicago Bears
- Statistical Excellence: 1985 Chicago Bears
- Longevity of Greatness: 1985 Chicago Bears
- Clutch Performance: 2017 Philadelphia Eagles
- Legacy Endurance: 1985 Chicago Bears
FINAL SCORE: 1985 Chicago Bears 8 – 2017 Philadelphia Eagles 2
Final Verdict
The 2017 Eagles deserve far more respect than an 8-2 score might suggest. Philadelphia wins Strength of Competition and Clutch Performance because its championship run demanded extraordinary adaptability and nerve. The Eagles lost their starting quarterback, trusted Nick Foles, survived the NFC playoffs, and then defeated a New England dynasty on the sport’s biggest stage. That combination makes them one of the most memorable underdog champions of the modern era.
Chicago advances because its case reaches across nearly every other definition of greatness. The Bears win Dominance Over Competition, Championship Achievement, Star Power, Depth and Supporting Cast, Historical Impact, Statistical Excellence, Longevity of Greatness, and Legacy Endurance. Their 15-1 record and defensive production would already make them special, but the postseason elevated the season into something even larger. Chicago did not simply win the Super Bowl; it created one of the clearest examples of a championship team imposing its identity on an entire league.
Philadelphia’s resilience makes the Eagles dangerous, and their victory over New England guarantees permanent football lore. But the 1985 Bears combine peak dominance, elite talent, statistical force, cultural personality, and decades of historical staying power at a level very few teams can match. The #16 seed produces two meaningful category victories, but the tournament’s #1 seed proves too complete to upset in the opening round.
Final Result: 1985 Chicago Bears advance by a score of 8-2.
Audience Challenge
Could Nick Foles, Doug Pederson, and Philadelphia’s fearless offense have found enough answers against the legendary 46 Defense, or would Chicago’s pressure and physicality have overwhelmed even the Eagles’ deepest strengths? If you think Philadelphia deserved another category, which one would you flip? Make your case for whether the underdog champions could have pushed the 1985 Bears closer in Gametime Gauntlet.
