Complete-team dominance meets one of baseball’s most unforgettable championship runs.
The fourth first-round matchup in the MLB Region brings together two World Series champions whose greatness was built in very different ways. The #4 seed 1970 Baltimore Orioles were a complete baseball machine, combining elite pitching, dependable defense, power, depth, and remarkable regular-season consistency. Their 108-win season was followed by a dominant postseason that ended with a World Series championship.
Across the bracket stands the #13 seed 2001 Arizona Diamondbacks, a much younger franchise that produced an unforgettable title run. Arizona was powered by the extraordinary one-two pitching combination of Randy Johnson and Curt Schilling, but the team’s legacy reaches beyond its aces. The Diamondbacks survived a dramatic seven-game World Series against the New York Yankees and produced one of the most memorable championship finishes in modern baseball history.
Gametime Gauntlet does not ask which team would literally win a series against the other. The teams are judged relative to their own eras across the tournament’s ten official criteria. Baltimore enters with the advantages of balance, sustained excellence, and roster depth, while Arizona counters with elite top-end pitching, a difficult championship opponent, and extraordinary October drama. Let the showdown begin.
Affiliate Disclaimer
This blog may contain affiliate links or banner advertisements. If you click on one of these links or advertisements and make a purchase, The Shopping Plaza may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. These commissions help support our work and allow us to continue creating free sports content, rankings, tournament features, and Legacy Showdown matchups like Gametime Gauntlet. We only recommend products, services, or merchandise that we believe may be of interest to our readers. Thank you for supporting The Shopping Plaza and Gametime Gauntlet.
Gametime Gauntlet Judging Rules
Each team is judged relative to its own era. Modern training, technology, and strategic advantages are ignored, and the focus is historical greatness rather than a hypothetical head-to-head game or series. One point is awarded in each of the ten categories, and the team winning the majority of categories advances.
- Dominance Over Competition
The 1970 Orioles won 108 regular-season games, immediately placing them among the most dominant clubs of their era. Baltimore finished comfortably atop the American League East and demonstrated excellence over the long grind of a 162-game schedule rather than relying on a short late-season surge. Their strength carried directly into October, where they swept Minnesota in the American League Championship Series before defeating Cincinnati in the World Series.
The 2001 Diamondbacks were excellent as well, winning 92 games and taking the National League West, but their regular-season control was not comparable to Baltimore’s 108-win campaign. Arizona’s greatness became most dramatic in the postseason, while Baltimore established overwhelming superiority for virtually the entire year. The Orioles therefore hold the clearer advantage when the category asks how thoroughly a team controlled its competition from beginning to end.
Winner: 1970 Baltimore Orioles
- Championship Achievement
Both teams completed their seasons with the only accomplishment that ultimately matters most: a World Series championship. Arizona’s title deserves enormous respect because the Diamondbacks defeated the three-time defending champion New York Yankees in a seven-game classic. Baltimore, however, paired its championship with one of the strongest regular seasons in franchise history and a postseason in which the club consistently looked like the best team in baseball.
The Orioles swept the ALCS and then beat a formidable Cincinnati Reds club in five games in the World Series. That combination of 108 regular-season victories and decisive postseason success creates a nearly complete championship résumé. Arizona’s path was more dramatic, but Baltimore’s title season was more comprehensively dominant. In this category, the Orioles receive the narrow edge.
Winner: 1970 Baltimore Orioles
- Strength of Competition
This is where the 2001 Diamondbacks make one of their strongest arguments. Their World Series opponent was not simply a famous Yankees team; New York entered the Fall Classic as the three-time defending champion and had won four of the previous five World Series. Defeating that kind of established dynasty required Arizona to overcome an opponent with enormous postseason experience, star power, and confidence.
Baltimore also faced excellent competition, including a Cincinnati team loaded with talent and a Minnesota club that had won its division. Yet Arizona’s championship opponent carried an unusual historical weight because the Yankees were attempting to extend one of modern baseball’s defining dynasties. The Diamondbacks had to survive seven games and multiple emotionally crushing moments before finally finishing the job. That championship obstacle gives Arizona the edge in Strength of Competition.
Winner: 2001 Arizona Diamondbacks
- Star Power
The 1970 Orioles had legitimate star power throughout the roster. Brooks Robinson was already one of baseball’s premier defensive third basemen and produced a legendary World Series performance, while Frank Robinson remained a dangerous middle-of-the-order presence. Boog Powell supplied MVP-level production, and Jim Palmer fronted a deep pitching staff that would become synonymous with Baltimore excellence.
But Arizona possessed a pairing at the top of its rotation that became the defining force of the 2001 championship. Randy Johnson and Curt Schilling were not merely excellent starters; together they dominated the postseason and shared World Series MVP honors. Johnson’s overwhelming power and Schilling’s command gave Arizona two pitchers capable of changing an entire series. Baltimore had more star talent spread across the roster, but the extraordinary peak of Arizona’s two aces gives the Diamondbacks the narrow edge here.
Winner: 2001 Arizona Diamondbacks
- Depth and Supporting Cast
The 1970 Orioles demonstrate exactly why this category exists. Baltimore could beat opponents with power, pitching, defense, or contributions from players outside the biggest names. Frank Robinson, Brooks Robinson, Boog Powell, and Jim Palmer supplied elite talent, but the roster also included important contributors such as Davey Johnson, Paul Blair, Mark Belanger, Mike Cuellar, and Dave McNally.
The pitching staff was particularly imposing because opponents could not simply survive one ace and expect relief against the rest of the rotation. Arizona had valuable contributors beyond Johnson and Schilling, including Luis Gonzalez, Matt Williams, Steve Finley, and others who played critical roles in the championship season. Still, Baltimore’s excellence was distributed more evenly throughout the roster. The Orioles’ combination of position-player depth, pitching depth, defense, and organizational stability wins this category.
Winner: 1970 Baltimore Orioles
- Historical Impact
The 1970 Orioles were part of a Baltimore organization that became a model of sustained baseball excellence. Their success represented the famous “Oriole Way,” an organizational identity built around fundamentals, player development, pitching, defense, and consistency. The club’s run during the late 1960s and early 1970s helped establish Baltimore as one of the defining powers of its era.
The 2001 Diamondbacks created history of a different kind by winning a championship only a few seasons after the franchise began play. Their victory also ended the Yankees’ run of three consecutive World Series titles and gave Arizona one of the most dramatic championship moments in baseball history. Even so, the Orioles’ influence was tied to a broader period of organizational excellence and a sustained model of winning. Baltimore takes Historical Impact.
Winner: 1970 Baltimore Orioles
- Statistical Excellence
Baltimore’s 108 victories provide the strongest opening argument in this category, but the case goes deeper than the win total. The Orioles combined high-level run production with a pitching staff capable of controlling games across an entire season. Their statistical profile reflected balance: this was not a club surviving because one unit covered for another major weakness.
Arizona’s numbers were impressive in their own right, particularly because Johnson and Schilling produced elite strikeout totals and gave the Diamondbacks exceptional starting pitching at the top of the rotation. Luis Gonzalez also delivered a huge offensive season, giving Arizona a legitimate middle-of-the-order force. However, the Orioles’ statistics better reflected dominance across the complete roster and over the full regular season. Baltimore’s 108-win performance and all-around excellence earn the point.
Winner: 1970 Baltimore Orioles
- Longevity of Greatness
The 1970 Orioles were not an isolated championship team that appeared suddenly and disappeared. Baltimore reached the World Series in 1969, won it in 1970, and returned again in 1971, making this team part of a sustained period of American League dominance. The organization had already won the 1966 World Series and continued to contend through a core built around pitching, defense, and established stars.
Arizona remained competitive after 2001 and returned to the postseason, but the championship team is remembered more as the brilliant peak of that particular Diamondbacks era than as the center of a comparable multi-year dynasty. Johnson and Schilling gave Arizona an extraordinary championship window, yet Baltimore’s surrounding run of pennants and elite seasons was more sustained. The Orioles therefore hold a decisive advantage in Longevity of Greatness.
Winner: 1970 Baltimore Orioles
- Clutch Performance
Baltimore was outstanding in the 1970 postseason and deserves credit for making championship baseball look controlled rather than chaotic. The Orioles swept Minnesota and then defeated Cincinnati in five games, showing that they could translate regular-season superiority directly into October success. Brooks Robinson’s World Series performance became one of the signature individual displays in championship history.
Yet Arizona’s 2001 World Series victory is almost the definition of clutch drama. The Diamondbacks had to recover from painful late-game losses in New York, force the series back to Arizona, and then face Mariano Rivera in the ninth inning of Game 7. Instead of folding against the sport’s most dominant closer and a dynasty accustomed to winning these moments, Arizona rallied and won the championship on Luis Gonzalez’s walk-off hit. Few championship endings carry more pressure or remain more vividly remembered. The Diamondbacks take Clutch Performance.
Winner: 2001 Arizona Diamondbacks
- Legacy Endurance
More than half a century later, the 1970 Orioles remain a reference point whenever baseball historians discuss the greatest complete teams in franchise or American League history. Their 108 wins, championship, star-studded roster, elite pitching, and Brooks Robinson’s World Series heroics have preserved their place in baseball memory. They also represent the peak of an Orioles era that remains central to the franchise’s identity.
The 2001 Diamondbacks have an enduring legacy of their own, especially because Game 7 remains one of the most famous World Series finishes ever. Johnson and Schilling’s postseason work ensures that the team will always be remembered when great pitching duos are discussed. But Arizona’s legacy is often centered on the championship series and its dramatic ending, whereas Baltimore’s reputation encompasses the entire construction and dominance of the team. The broader historical résumé gives the Orioles the final category.
Winner: 1970 Baltimore Orioles
Gametime Gauntlet Scorecard
Dominance Over Competition: 1970 Baltimore Orioles
Championship Achievement: 1970 Baltimore Orioles
Strength of Competition: 2001 Arizona Diamondbacks
Star Power: 2001 Arizona Diamondbacks
Depth and Supporting Cast: 1970 Baltimore Orioles
Historical Impact: 1970 Baltimore Orioles
Statistical Excellence: 1970 Baltimore Orioles
Longevity of Greatness: 1970 Baltimore Orioles
Clutch Performance: 2001 Arizona Diamondbacks
Legacy Endurance: 1970 Baltimore Orioles
FINAL SCORE: 1970 Baltimore Orioles 7 – 2001 Arizona Diamondbacks 3
Final Verdict
This matchup reveals why Gametime Gauntlet evaluates greatness across multiple dimensions. The 2001 Diamondbacks possess a championship story that can stand beside almost any modern World Series winner. Randy Johnson and Curt Schilling gave Arizona historic top-end pitching, the club defeated a dynasty-level Yankees opponent, and its Game 7 victory produced an ending that remains permanently embedded in baseball history.
But the 1970 Orioles win because their greatness was less dependent on one extraordinary October storyline. Baltimore dominated over the full regular season, possessed superior overall depth, belonged to a sustained championship-level run, and combined elite pitching, defense, offense, and star power with very few obvious weaknesses. Arizona wins the categories that celebrate the difficulty and drama of its championship journey, while Baltimore wins the categories that measure complete-season superiority and sustained organizational greatness.
The 7-3 score is therefore more decisive than the difference in championship quality. Arizona was absolutely capable of beating an elite opponent when everything was on the line. Baltimore simply checks more boxes when the entire definition of historical team greatness is considered.
Final Result: 1970 Baltimore Orioles advance by a score of 7-3.
Audience Challenge
Would Randy Johnson and Curt Schilling be enough for you to push the 2001 Diamondbacks past Baltimore’s deeper and more balanced roster? Does Arizona deserve additional credit for defeating the Yankees dynasty in one of the greatest World Series ever played, or should 108 wins and the Orioles’ sustained excellence carry more weight? Which of the ten categories would you change, and would your changes be enough to reverse the 7-3 result? Make your case and tell us which champion deserves to advance in Gametime Gauntlet.
